Yawmy guide8 min read

Employee Performance Review Form: A Template to Copy

An employee performance review form you can copy: rating scale, weighted criteria, a worked score, bias checks, and the facts to pull from attendance and tasks.

Nada HassanHR-Tech Strategist, YawmyCanonical link

An employee performance review form is a short, structured sheet that records how well a person met agreed expectations over a period, so the conversation about pay, development or a probation decision rests on written facts instead of impressions. A good one fits on a single page, uses a rating scale everyone understands, and separates what was achieved from how the person behaved. This guide gives you a copyable template, a worked scoring example, the bias checks that keep reviews fair, and a note on which facts to collect before you sit down.

TL;DR. Use five to seven criteria, each with a short definition and a 1 to 5 scale. Weight them by role. Collect evidence before the meeting, score alone first, then discuss. Record the employee's own comments and a signature. If the result may lead to a penalty or termination, follow the process in the current Egyptian Labour Law and your regulation, and consult a lawyer. This is general information, not legal advice.

This piece supports our guide to employee attendance software in Egypt, because attendance is one of the few review inputs that is a fact rather than an opinion.

Decide what the review is for

One form cannot serve every purpose well, so name the purpose at the top.

  • Probation review. Should this person be confirmed in the role at the end of the trial period? It is short and focused on basics.
  • Annual or half-yearly review. How did the year go, and what should change? This is where goals and development live.
  • Problem review. A documented conversation about a specific shortfall. If it can lead to a penalty, treat it as a disciplinary file, as described in our warning letter guide.

Mixing the three produces a form that is too long for probation and too shallow for the annual cycle.

The template

Copy this structure into a document or spreadsheet. Fill the header and criteria before the meeting, and leave the comment boxes for the conversation.

Header: employee name, job title, department or branch, manager, review period, review type (probation, annual, problem), date of meeting.

Part 1: criteria and ratings

Criterion What it means for this role Weight Rating (1 to 5) Evidence
Quality of work Accuracy, completeness, few redo cycles 30% Examples, error log
Reliability Attendance, punctuality, meets deadlines 20% Attendance report, task dates
Ownership of tasks Finishes and reports back without chasing 20% Task list, manager notes
Teamwork and communication Helps colleagues, clear updates 15% Peer or manager input
Learning and initiative Picks up new skills, suggests fixes 15% Concrete cases

Weights should total 100% and should change with the role. A cashier may carry more weight on reliability, an accountant on accuracy.

Part 2: goals for the next period. Two to four goals, each with a measurable outcome and a date.

Part 3: development. One training or support item the company will provide.

Part 4: comments. A box for the manager, a box for the employee, then names, signatures and dates. An employee who disagrees can say so in writing, and the form should leave room for it.

The rating scale

A scale only works if each number means the same thing to every manager. Define them once.

Score Label Plain meaning
1 Below expectations Needs immediate, close support to reach the basics
2 Partly meets Some parts met, others missing; clear gap
3 Meets expectations Does the role well and consistently
4 Exceeds in places Regularly goes beyond the role in specific areas
5 Outstanding Sets the standard others copy; rare

Tell managers that a 3 is a good result. If everyone is rated 4 or 5 the scale stops carrying information, and the one person who deserves a 5 cannot be told apart.

A worked score

Take an employee rated as follows against the weights above. These numbers are an invented example, not a benchmark.

Criterion Weight Rating Weighted (weight x rating)
Quality of work 30% 4 1.20
Reliability 20% 3 0.60
Ownership of tasks 20% 4 0.80
Teamwork and communication 15% 3 0.45
Learning and initiative 15% 5 0.75
Total 100% 3.80

A total of 3.80 sits between "meets" and "exceeds in places". The number starts the conversation; it does not end it. Decide in advance what, if anything, the score triggers, such as eligibility for a raise discussion, and write that rule down. Do not let a score alone decide pay or termination.

Collect facts before you sit down

The most common failure is writing the form the night before from memory. Memory favours the last month and the loudest events. Spend an hour gathering evidence for the whole period.

  1. Attendance and punctuality. Pull the monthly figures: days present, lateness, approved leave. Our attendance report format shows what to include.
  2. Task completion. List assigned tasks, due dates and completion dates. If you follow up through a system, export it. See how to follow up on employee tasks.
  3. Examples. Note two or three specific cases, good and bad, with dates.
  4. Onboarding goals for probation reviews. Compare against what was promised in the new employee checklist.
  5. Prior notes. Last review's goals and what happened to them.

Separate the lists into things you saw yourself and things you were told. Second-hand claims need checking before they go on the form.

Bias checks before you finalise

Reviews fail through habits more than through bad intent. Run through these five.

  • Recency. Did one recent event outweigh eleven ordinary months? Look at the full period.
  • Halo and horns. Is one strong or weak area colouring every rating?
  • Similarity. Are you rating people higher because they work like you or share your background?
  • Leniency or severity. Do you give most people the same score? Compare your ratings across the team.
  • Attendance traps. Do not mark someone down for approved leave, a documented illness or other protected absence. Treat only unplanned, unexcused patterns as a reliability issue.

Score alone first, then compare with any second opinion, then meet. Telling the employee the criteria at the start of the period, not at the review, is the single most effective fairness measure.

Run the meeting

Allow forty-five minutes. Open with what went well, then move to gaps with specific examples, ask for the employee's view, and agree goals together. Ask "what would help you do this better?" before offering solutions. End by confirming what will be written and who will sign. Keep a copy on the personnel file and give a copy to the employee.

If the review exposes a serious performance or conduct problem, do not improvise a penalty in the meeting. Egyptian labour law sets conditions for disciplinary action and termination, including written procedures. Check the current text of the Labour Law on the Ministry of Manpower site, compare it with your regulation and consult a labour lawyer. The ILO also publishes general material on performance and employment practice.

How Yawmy fits

Yawmy records check-in and check-out and keeps task follow-up and attendance reports in one place, so reliability and task facts for the review period can be pulled from records rather than recalled. It does not score people for you, and the rating decisions stay with the manager. The free plan covers 2 employees; Pro is 500 EGP per month or 4,500 EGP per year with unlimited employees. See the Yawmy site for current details.

FAQ

How many criteria should a review form have?

Five to seven is a practical range. Fewer misses important areas, and more makes managers tick boxes without thinking. Keep each criterion defined in one sentence.

Should the form be the same for every role?

Use the same structure but adjust the criteria and weights by role. A sales representative and an accountant should not be scored on identical definitions of quality.

How often should reviews happen?

Many small companies run a probation review at the end of the trial period and one or two reviews a year. Add short monthly check-ins so nothing in the review is a surprise.

Can I use the form to dismiss someone?

A review is evidence, not a termination procedure. Dismissal and penalties have legal conditions in Egypt. Follow the current Labour Law and your regulation, and ask a lawyer before acting.

Should the employee see the form before the meeting?

Sharing the criteria in advance is good practice. Whether to share the filled form beforehand depends on your culture; many managers share the self-assessment first and reveal ratings in the meeting.

Written by Nada Hassan, HR-Tech Strategist at Yawmy. This is general information, not legal advice.

To have attendance and task records ready for your next review cycle, open Yawmy or visit the Yawmy home page.

Want attendance and task facts ready before each review?

Tell us your team size and branches; your request goes straight to the Yawmy team.

Your details go to the sales team only.
Start here

Turn attendance and payroll into a clean system in minutes.

Try Yawmy for free, add your team, and connect Telegram check-ins, GPS proof, and payroll-ready reports without Excel or WhatsApp chaos.

Yawmy
GPS attendance
Payroll reports
Teams & branches
No hardware